From Criticism to Methodology: Dutch reflections on science and society 1926-1970


The methodological and philosophical reflections caused by the dramatic changes in science in the 20th-century have not lost a whiff of their urgency. When today we feel a need for clarity and rationality of language, it is good to be aware of the fountain of concept-critical thinking created over the past century. From the beginning of the 20th-century, concerns about ambiguities in communication in science and in general have inspired a community of intellectuals in The Netherlands to reflect thoroughly on language and understanding.

Parallel communities elsewhere in Europe, notably the Vienna Circle in Austria, and analytic philosophy originating in the Cambridge of G.E. Moore and B.A.W. Russell, developed into a dominant tradition in philosophy of our days. Within the Dutch concept-critical community a major stream of thought was developed by the Signific Circle. From Criticism to Methodology sets out to study the Dutch history of analytic philosophy, in the manner of the history of ideas, and thus to include a discussion of the content of these ideas and show their relevance for present concerns.

In contrast to the continuing interest in the history of analytic philosophy in other countries, notably the Wiener Kreis and British
analytic philosophy, the Dutch concept-critical tradition has been understudied.
We want to bridge this gap in the Dutch and European history of ideas, with an emphasis on the period from 1930 till 1970. From Criticism to Methodology
will achieve this by studying the works of the leading persons involved: Gerrit Mannoury (Significs, or theory of means of communication, and didactics), David van Dantzig (Significs, foundations of probability theory, methodology, information theory, Unesco), Evert Willem Beth (logic, foundations of the exact sciences, philosophy of science and methodology), and Arend Jan Heyting (intuitionistic mathematics and logic). Beyond the published works, archives in Amsterdam and Haarlem hold a wealth of unpublished manuscripts, typescripts, and letters waiting to be studied and disclosed. The results will offer a long due contribution to the international discourse on the history of analytic philosophy, logic, methodology and philosophy of science, which have been attracting intense and wide attention over the past decades.


Professionele publicatie

  • G. Alberts(2013): Tussen Tannery en Klein: polariteit in de geschiedschrijving van de wiskunde in België en Nederland pp. 173 - 186
  • G. Alberts(2013): Dirk Jan Struik (1894-2000) pp. 271 - 275


  • P. van Ulsen(2013): Wiskunde-onderwijs
  • P. van Ulsen(2013): Introductie van logica en wetenschappelijke wijsbegeerte aan de Nederlandse universiteiten
  • P. van Ulsen(2013): Organisaties en genootschappen
  • M. Kirkels(2013): Gerrit Mannoury?s signific philosophy
  • G. Alberts(2013): Tussen Tannery en Klein: polariteit in de geschiedschrijving van de wiskunde in België en Nederland





Prof. dr. F.A. Muller

Verbonden aan

Erasmus Universiteit Rotterdam, Faculteit der Wijsbegeerte, Theoretische Filosofie


Dr. G. Alberts, Drs. M.P.A. Kirkels, Prof. dr. F.A. Muller, Prof. dr. F.A. Muller, Dr. P. van Ulsen


01/03/2012 tot 01/07/2017