RESPonsible innovation: linking formal and infOrmal assessmeNt in deciSion-making on Energy projects (RESPONSE)

Summary

New energy technologies are sources of controversy; think of public opposition to wind parks. Controversies arise from value conflicts between stakeholders. Responsible innovation suggests that the diversity of relevant values is assessed and carefully evaluated in the development and implementation of energy projects. Whereas controversy is often seen as a barrier to implementation, we take the position that controversies can be regarded as an informal assessment of the energy project. Controversies articulate the conflicting values at stake and reveal unanticipated societal and ethical risks, and associated costs and benefits. We distinguish informal assessment from formal assessment. Formal assessment involves tools such as environmental impact assessment and (social) cost-benefit analysis to evaluate and ascertain formally established public values, associated with safety, health and economy. However, such (legally) formalized tools cannot cover the wide and variable range of values that an energy project puts at stake for different people in society. As a result, formal assessment methods often become debated in controversy, for instance because their scope and process is not considered appropriate for the project at hand. As such they can be seen as imperfect (and sometimes even counterproductive) in supporting public-private decision-making for socially responsible energy projects. To overcome this problem we aim to develop a methodology to enrich the assessment of energy projects by linking formal assessment to societal informal assessment. We will do so by 1) ex-post analysis of (non)controversial energy projects and 2) action research in running projects in which the methodology will be developed and evaluated.

Keywords:
1. Energy
2. Controversy
3. Assessment
4. Public values
5. Institutions
6. Stakeholder participation

Output

Chapter in book

  • A Correljé, U Pesch, B Taebi, E van de Grift, E Cuppen(2017): Responsible Innovation pp. 131 - 148

Scientific article

Professional publication

Publication meant for a broad audience

Publications for the general public

Details

Project number

313-99-303

Main applicant

Dr. ir. E.H.W.J. Cuppen

Affiliated with

Technische Universiteit Delft, Faculteit Techniek, Bestuur en Management, Beleidskunde

Team members

Drs. E.M.H.R. van de Grift, Drs. E.M.H.R. van de Grift, Drs. S.L. Spruit

Duration

01/09/2015 to 31/08/2019