The Artificial Ethicists

Summary

Imagine an artificial intelligence (AI) that could advise you on what to do—e.g., whether to become a pacifist; when to react to injustice; how to balance courage and caution. It could tell you what you should do, given your values and principles, or what you should do, given the set of values and principles that it thinks you should have. Drawing on machine learning and vast datasets on human actions, reactions, judgments, and theories, it has acquired, among other things, concepts of morality and obligation. I call this AI an artificial ethicist (AE).

An AE would likely disagree with you sometimes—even about what your most fundamental values should be. In some cases, it might be able to explain why you should modify your values, but given the gulf between its abilities and yours, it is unlikely that you—or any human—could understand all its arguments.

Recent advances in AI research give us compelling reasons to consider this kind of scenario now. Furthermore, AEs supply a new angle from which to consider foundational questions about human morality.

This scenario raises a question:
• Under what conditions, if any, should one defer to the moral expertise of an artificial ethicist?
Drawing on analytic moral epistemology and recent work from AI researchers, I will address this question in three steps:
1. I will investigate what features AEs would likely have and in what ways AEs would be different from humans offering moral testimony or expertise.
2. I will examine our options for evaluating the reliability of the AE’s judgments.
3. I will assess whether there are epistemic or moral reasons for declining to defer to the expertise of an AE, even if one has good reasons to think the AE’s moral judgments are more reliable than one’s own.

Details

Project number

016.Veni.195.513

Main applicant

Dr. E.R.H. O'Neill

Affiliated with

Technische Universiteit Eindhoven, Faculteit Industrial Engineering & Innovation Sciences, Philosophy & Ethics (Phil&Ethics)

Team members

Dr. E.R.H. O'Neill, Dr. E.R.H. O'Neill

Duration

01/02/2019 to 31/10/2021