Even neighbourhoods with higher-educated ethnic minorities arouse resistance

6 January 2012

The resistance towards ethnically mixed neighbourhoods decreases if higher-educated people from ethnic minorities live there. Yet even then a large proportion of the autochthonous Dutch population still prefer to avoid neighbourhoods with a high concentration of people from ethnic minorities. This is the conclusion of NWO-funded researcher Marieke van Londen who will defend her PhD thesis on 12 January at the Radboud University Nijmegen.

Van Londen studied the resistance Dutch people have towards living in ethnically mixed neighbourhoods. Participants in a representative large-scale questionnaire survey were asked to what extent they would object to living in neighbourhoods with various concentrations of people from ethnic minorities. The assumption is that autochthonous Dutch people are reluctant to live in ethnically mixed neighbourhoods as they associate these with an educational disadvantage. They are then supposedly afraid that the lower-educated ethnic minorities will have different norms and values.

'My research partly confirms this view,' explains Van Londen. 'If people hear that higher-educated minorities live in black neighbourhoods then their resistance towards living in such a neighbourhood does indeed decrease. However, at the same time one-quarter of the respondents indicated that if more than half the residents from such a neighbourhood were from ethnic minorities then they would still rather leave the neighbourhood irrespective of the educational level of the people concerned.' Just like any research into ethnic prejudices I can imagine that people give socially desirable answers says Van Londen. 'In practice this means that the resistance towards ethnically mixed neighbourhoods could be even greater still.'

Education

Van Londen also investigated people's feelings towards the policy of supporting ethnic minorities in education. She concludes that people's resistance to this depends on how the policy is presented. For example, the resistance is higher if it is emphasised that the policy can be to the detriment of attention for autochthonous children. However, the resistance drops slightly if the message clearly states that the policy increases the chances for children from ethnic minorities. 'Yet the effect of how you present the policy is relatively weak,' states Van Londen. Furthermore, the resistance to the ethnic schooling policy increases if both the advantages for the ethnic minorities and the disadvantages for the autochthonous pupils are emphasised. 'This situation is closer to the everyday reality where people often hear several partly conflicting arguments with respect to the same policy issue,' says Van Londen.

Van Londen did her doctoral research at Radboud University Nijmegen. Her work was funded by the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO).

About NWO

The Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO) is the national research council in the Netherlands and has a budget of more than 500 million euros per year. NWO promotes quality and innovation in science by selecting and funding the best research. NWO manages research institutes of national and international importance, contributes to strategic programming of scientific research and brings science and society closer together. Research proposals are reviewed and selected by researchers of international repute. More than 5000 scientists can carry out research thanks to funding from NWO.

Source: NWO

Details

Further information

NWO, Information and Communication Department, tel.: +31 70 344 07 41